Search SchoolNGR

Saturday, 21 November 2026
Register . Login

Yahaya bought a piece of furniture on a credit sale agreement from Ahmed and resold it ...

Yahaya bought a piece of furniture on a credit sale agreement from Ahmed and resold it to Ali before all installments were made .The court upheld that Ahmed could not recover possession of the items from Ali. The reason for the judgement was because
Take Free Practice Test On 2026 JAMB UTME, Post UTME, WAEC SSCE, GCE, NECO SSCE
  • A Ownership was transfered on completeion of installment
  • B Ownership was transfered on delivery
  • C Yahaya could not pass title to a third party
  • D Ali was still indebted to Yahaya
Correct Answer: Option B
Explanation:
This case turns on the legal difference between a credit sale agreement and a hire purchase agreement. Under a credit sale agreement, ownership (title) of the goods passes to the buyer immediately upon delivery, even though the buyer is allowed to pay in installments. This is different from a hire purchase agreement, where ownership only passes after the final installment is paid.<br/><br/>Since ownership passed to Yahaya upon delivery, Yahaya became the legal owner of the furniture. As the legal owner, he had the right to sell or transfer the furniture to anyone, including Ali. Ali now holds valid title to the goods. Ahmed's only remedy is to sue Yahaya for the unpaid balance of the purchase price, because the debt is between Ahmed and Yahaya. Ahmed cannot recover the physical goods from Ali because Ali is now the rightful owner.

Share question on: